Sunday, September 13, 2009


In the wake of Rep. Joe Wilson's outburst during Obama's address to Congress, there are calls for his censure, online petitions denouncing his actions, and probably much worse. (I liked this line from Tigerhawk:"What is it with guys named Joe Wilson? Do they all accuse presidents of lying?")

For some, Wilson's rudeness is THE sudden collapse of civility and manners. Our political discourse has now been plunged into some unprecedented sewer depths.


Look--Wilson's act was rude and certainly displayed a distinct lack of class. He apologized directly to the President, who accepted his apology without qualification. Apparently that's not enough for some. Wilson is a racist, they say. He proves Republicans are a**holes, they say. House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer ( D-MD) said: “I have never in my 29 years heard an outburst of that nature with reference to a president of the United States speaking as a guest of the House and Senate.”

Really? Gonna have to get Hoyer some new Beltones. I found this over at a blog called Cranky Conservative. It's a youtube rundwon of various examples of "civility" that didn't seem to spark any outrage from the Left. Highlights from the list:

--Bush getting booed at the Obama inaugural
--Rep. Baron Hill from Indiana--"This is MY town hall meeting . . ." Yep--he's a Dem.
--Democrats booing--BOOING--Bush during the 2005 State of the Union address. Watch the clip--the noise is somewhat prolonged and widespread, in contrast to Wilson's rather limited outburst. Was Hoyer asleep or what?
--Gore's "How Dare They" speech to in 2004. ("How dare the incompetent and willful members of this Bush/Cheney Administration humiliate our nation and our people in the eyes of the world and in the conscience of our own people. How dare they subject us to such dishonor and disgrace. How dare they drag the good name of the United States of America through the mud of Saddam Hussein's torture prison.")
--Sen. Durbin comparing American soldiers to Nazis and to those who ran the Gulags.
--Sen. John Murtha saying that our troops killed "innocent civilians in cold blood."

And yet, the outrage, the spotlight is on Wilson for his rather rude remark. Don't get me wrong--Wilson was wrong in what he did. No matter what has passed for political discourse in the last 8 years should not give the Republicans a license to engage in the same tactics.

But if you are suddenly purple with indignation about the lack of civility, you are perhaps a little late to the game.

The headline for a recent article perhaps said it best:
Show me a country without lawyers, hobos, and fighting politicians and I'll show you a dictatorship.


Anonymous said...

My favorite thing about Addison Graves Wilson (and what is it with Republicans and their endless stable of fake "Joe's"?) is that he voted to provide free health care to illegals in the 2003 Medicare Prescription Bill... which was unfunded to the tune of 11 trillion dollars. The uproar from "conservatives" in the streets was truly awe-inspiring, wasn't it?

Anonymous said...

Abbey St.Walburga
Ace O' Spades
Adoration Online
A Few Shiny Pebbles
A.J. Strata
Another Think
Ann Althouse
And You Thought/Cranky
American Digest
American Thinker
Aussie Homilies
Betsy's Page
Beyond the Pale
Big Hollywood
Blue Crab Blvd
Bill Whittle
Bookworm Room
Brutally Honest
Busted Halo
Cardinal Sean's Blog
Catholic Answers
Catholic Manhattan
Catholic Media Review
Cathouse Chat
Cartago Delenda Est
Catholic Key
Classical Values
Compulsive Copyeditor
Confederate Yankee
Conversion Diary
Curt Jester
Danielle Bean
Dave Justus
David Warren
Dawn Eden
Day by Day Cartoon
Deacon's Bench
Desert Nuns
Doc is In
Dominican Nuns, Summit
Don Singleton
Don Surber
Doug Ross Journal
Dr. Melissa Clouthier
Dr. Helen
Dr. Sanity
Ed Driscoll
Eternity Road
Evangelical Outpost
Ezra Levant
Fausta's Blog
Fine Old Family
Five Feet of Fury
Flopping Aces
Fr. Dwight Longenecker
Fr. Steve's Blog
G.M. Roper
Gateway Pundit
Gay Patriot
Goldfish & Clowns
Happy Catholic
Hot Air
Hubble Telescope
Inside Catholic
J's CafeNette
Jules Crittenden
Just One Minute
Kentucky Packrat
Kim Priestap
Life as a Catholic
Liturgy of the Hours
Lorie Byrd
Maggie's Farm
Mahsheed's Corner
Martha, Martha
Maternal Optimist
Maxed Out Mama
McNamara's Blog
Meanwhile/in the Kitchen
Media Mythbusters
Michelle Malkin
Mike Rowe Works
Minding the Campus
Moderate Voice
Musing Minds
New Advent
New Wine
Noisy Room Blog
Nose on your Face (satire)
Obi's Sister
Okie on the Lam
One Cosmos
Paragraph Farmer
Passionist Nuns
Paul Snatchko
People's Cube
Planet Gore
Pioneer Woman
Powerline Blog
Protein Wisdom
Pursuing Holiness
Stones Cry Out
Sundries Shack
Rachel Lucas
Real Clear Politics
Right Wing News
Right Wing Nuthouse
Roman Catholic Vocations
Scribal Terror
Sissy Willis
Sister Toldjah
Small Dead Animals
Some Have Hats
Spiritual Things Matter
St. Joseph's Monastery
Stop the ACLU
Sweetness & Light
Tammy Bruce
Tim Blair
Villainous Company
Vita Nostra In Ecclesia
Volokh Conspiracy
Western Chauvinist
Whispers in the Loggia
Wide Awake Cafe
Wintery Knight Blog
Why I Am Catholic

A partial of list right wing news sources that have devoted a total of 0 words to the fact that Addison Graves Wilson had recently voted to fund health care for illegal aliens. Maybe if I dressed up as a pimp....